fivemack: (Default)
Tom Womack ([personal profile] fivemack) wrote2008-10-05 07:36 pm

Dumb economic question

It seems that the current Something To Do about the credit crunch is to provide Government backing of private bank deposits without limit - Ireland, Greece, and now Germany, and a punditry belief that once Germany has gone the insurance will be extended across the EU.

How does this help, when the immediate consequence of the credit crunch that keeps coming up is an inability of banks to issue short-term business loans, with a secondary concern about businesses losing float kept in their accounts with failing banks and being obliged to close.

It doesn't make the banks any more solvent, it just makes their insolvency less visible, and means that in the event of the bank running out of money I get repaid out of the National Debt, which I then presumably get to repay out of raised taxes over the next half-century.

[identity profile] papersky.livejournal.com 2008-10-06 02:25 pm (UTC)(link)
I have no idea.

I had an idea for something that would fix this -- set all mortgage rates by fiat to 5%. It doesn't reward any villains or the imprudent over the prudent, and it would actually work.

[identity profile] arnhem.livejournal.com 2008-10-06 04:05 pm (UTC)(link)
That'll make the arbitrageurs very happy; I'm not sure whether to characterise them as villains or not.